Knowledge / Measurement principles compared
For long-term monitoring of small differential pressures below 2 kPa, there is one measuring principle that is structurally unbeatable — and three that require regular intervention. The difference is not price, it is physics: electronic sensors age. The ring balance does not.
The four principles compared
| Property | Ring balance | Diaphragm (strain gauge) | Capacitive | Piezoresistive |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Measurement path | mechanical (torque) | electrical (strain) | electrical (capacitance) | electrical (resistance) |
| Drift over 10 years | physically zero | 0.2–1 % p.a. | 0.1–0.5 % p.a. | 0.3–1 % p.a. |
| Readjustment | not required (within specified operating conditions) | every 12–24 months | every 12–24 months | every 6–12 months |
| Minimum span | 40 Pa | 100 Pa | 50 Pa | 250 Pa |
| Maximum span | 1,800 Pa | several bar | several bar | hundreds of bar |
| Aggressive media | very good | medium | good | poor |
| Response / signal quality | span-dependent — low-pass damping at small spans, fast at large spans | ms — software damping in controller typically required | ms — post-filtering required | ms — post-filtering required |
| On-site display | analog 150×150 mm (standard) or digital LCD | digital, separate | digital | digital |
| Power supply | transmitter only (optional) | always | always | always |
| Service life | 30+ years documented | 5–10 years | 5–10 years | 5–10 years |
| ATEX capable | yes (intrinsically safe Ex ia) | yes | yes | yes |
Praxis
Some manufacturers position their electronic diaphragm sensors as a "maintenance-free alternative to the ring balance." This refers to the elimination of sealing fluid — a valid simplification. However, the decisive question is different: how long does the calibration stay stable?
Diaphragm-based differential pressure sensors have documented drift rates of typically 0.3–1 % per year. For a 15 Pa pressure cascade, that means a deviation of 2–7 Pa by the fifth year of operation — half the monitored pressure differential itself. The ring balance measures purely mechanically: no ageing component in the measurement path, physically zero drift, no drift-induced readjustment.
With minimum spans, a second effect comes into play: electronic transmitters for ranges such as 40 or 100 Pa generally contain sensors designed for much larger ranges (typically 750 to 2,500 Pa upper range limit), whose signal is electronically amplified onto the small measuring range — referred to in data sheets as “turndown”, e.g. 100:1. Since accuracy, temperature and stability figures refer to the sensor's upper range limit, these errors multiply relative to the configured range; for such minimum ranges, manufacturers moreover often guarantee long-term stability for only one year instead of ten. The ring balance measures 40 Pa natively — calibration weight and measuring element are designed for exactly this range.
For applications with long service intervals, regulated calibration requirements or aggressive media — cleanroom, GMP, pharma, biogas, furnace engineering — the ring balance is structurally the superior solution.
Is the ring balance right for your application?
01
How often should the device be readjusted or recalibrated?
02
Which medium is being measured?
03
What pressure span is required?
Recommended products
The three transmitters in detail: differential pressure transmitters compared
Your application
Send us your key data — span, medium, supply voltage, zone, environment — and we will tell you honestly which ring balance is the right choice.
Note: The content of this page is provided for general guidance and replaces neither the operator's risk assessment nor case-by-case verification by qualified personnel. Responsibility for sizing, equipment selection, installation and operation lies solely with the operator. Despite careful preparation, we accept no liability for accuracy or completeness; the currently valid edition of the applicable regulations and standards prevails.